Last updated: November 4, 2026
Almost every crypto signals channel on Telegram says it is accurate, verified or "90%+". Very few let you check it. We went through the biggest signal groups and asked one question: can an outsider actually see the results, losing trades included, and are they posted as they happen or typed up at the end of the month?
This is the list of the channels that passed, ranked by how transparent they are. It is not a list of who makes the most money, because nobody can prove that without a full record. It is a list of whose numbers you can trust the most.
Live results, every trade, losses included: Bullstar Signals (our channel), tracked by Cornix in a public results channel.
Full monthly logs with losses: AltSignals and CoinCodeCap.
Results shown in R, not inflated percentages: CryptoNinjas Trading.
Biggest community with third-party stats: Binance Killers.
Weekly reports with red days: RAVEN Signals Pro.
The Most Transparent Crypto Signals Channels
| # | Channel | Live results | Losses shown | Score | Join |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Live | Every trade | 9.2 | Join free → | |
| 1 |  AltSignals 26.6K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Every trade | 6.7 | Join → |
| 2 |  CoinCodeCap 25.2K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Every trade | 6.7 | Join → |
| 3 |  Binance Killers 242K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Partial | 5.0 | Join → |
| 4 |  CryptoNinjas Trading 20.3K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Partial | 5.0 | Join → |
| 5 |  RAVEN Signals Pro 48.3K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Partial | 4.2 | Join → |
| 6 |  Evening Trader 13.6K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Partial | 4.2 | Join → |
| 7 |  Oldman Crypto 34.1K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Partial | 4.2 | Join → |
| 8 |  Fat Pig Signals 41.3K members · Monthly / weekly | Monthly / weekly | Partial | 3.3 | Join → |
Scores out of 10, from six checks worth up to 2 points each. Member counts checked on Telegram on November 4, 2026.
Why "Verified" Usually Isn't
Most channels prove their results with screenshots and monthly images. The problem is simple: anything made at the end of the month can leave trades out. A losing signal that never appears in the summary is invisible, and the win rate goes up.
That is why we gave the most weight to live results. When a bot like Cornix replies to a signal the moment a target or the stop loss is hit, each result has a timestamp and sits right under the original call. You can scroll back and see the losers next to the winners. Monthly reports still count, they are much better than nothing, but they earn half the points.
How We Checked Each Channel
Every channel was scored on the same six checks, worth 0, 1 or 2 points each. The total out of 12 is turned into a score out of 10.
| Check | 2 points | 1 point | 0 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Live results | Results are tracked live, trade by trade, as targets and stops are hit (for example by a Cornix bot replying to each signal) | Monthly or weekly reports only | No results reports |
| Full log with losses | Every trade is listed, losing trades included | Summaries or some losses shown | Only wins are shown |
| Stop loss on signals | Every signal has a written stop loss | Some signals have one | No stop losses |
| Independent check | Results tracked or audited by an outside party | Tracked by a bot such as Cornix, or partial third-party stats | Self-reported only |
| Public history | Two years or more of public results | Less than two years, or gaps | No history |
| Honest numbers | Win rates and profits that match the record, no hype | Some inflated totals | Claims like "90%+" or "guaranteed" that the record does not support |
The Channels, One by One
Bullstar Signals (our channel)
How results are shown: Every VIP signal is tracked by the Cornix bot, which replies to the signal the moment a target or the stop loss is hit. Those replies are forwarded to a public results channel, @BULLRESULT, and the same feed updates our results page on its own, so a trade cannot be added or removed after the fact.
What the numbers say: 911 VIP signals listed since June 2022, losses included. A signal only counts as a win at Target 3 or higher. If Target 2 is hit and the price then comes back, the trade is listed as breakeven at 0% and left out of the win rate, because our recommended Cornix setting moves the stop to the entry after Target 2.
What you can't check: Cornix tracks the trades, but the record is still published by us and not audited by an outside firm. We also run this site, so check the record yourself before you trust our score.
See the full VIP track record or follow the live feed on @BULLRESULT.
1. AltSignals
How results are shown: Running since 2017, AltSignals publishes a monthly report for each of its services that lists every trade, losing trades and losing months included.
What the numbers say: The reports are trade by trade, so you can check individual calls. Win rates move a lot from month to month and dropped to around 40% in July 2026, which they published instead of hiding.
What you can't check: Results are posted once a month, not live, and they are self-published. Monthly totals add up leveraged percentages, which makes the headline numbers look bigger than what most traders actually make. The free channel shows target updates rather than full signals you can test.
Read our full AltSignals review.
2. CoinCodeCap
How results are shown: CoinCodeCap posts a results page with every 2026 trade its bot reported, wins and losses, plus Google Sheets archives going back to 2021. Its free channel also shows Cornix target updates as they happen.
What the numbers say: Its own recount for January to September 2026 shows 521 trades, 283 wins and 235 losses, a 54.6% win rate, with three losing months. A third-party site, SmartOptions, also lists its Q3 2026 futures signals at a 52.41% win rate over 146 signals. Numbers this modest are a good sign: they look like a real record.
What you can't check: The full results are published monthly, not live. Data from February 2024 to December 2025 has not been recounted, and stop losses are only visible to paying members, so we could not check them in the free channel.
3. Binance Killers
How results are shown: The biggest channel on this list posts results in its free channel as targets are hit, and its monthly summaries admit losing trades. SmartOptions publishes quarterly stats on its signals.
What the numbers say: SmartOptions figures quoted for Q3 2026 show a 94.55% win rate over 68 signals, while another quarter shows 77.78%. The channel itself markets "92%+ accuracy".
What you can't check: There is no complete, trade-by-trade public history, so the accuracy claim cannot be checked by an outsider. The results posted live in the free channel are wins, and it is one of the most expensive VIP services in this space.
Read our full Binance Killers review.
4. CryptoNinjas Trading
How results are shown: Results are reported in R, the risk taken per trade, instead of inflated leveraged percentages, and some losing trades are posted in the open in weekly results.
What the numbers say: Every signal we saw had a stop loss. Reporting in R is one of the most honest ways to show signal results, because it cannot be pumped up with leverage.
What you can't check: In about 260 free channel posts, winning results far outnumbered the losses shown, and there is no full track record to check them against. VIP is pushed with repeated "ending in 24 hours" discounts.
Read our full CryptoNinjas Trading review.
5. RAVEN Signals Pro
How results are shown: RAVEN posts a weekly report for crypto and forex that includes losing days, and every signal we saw had a stop loss.
What the numbers say: The weekly reports show one total per day, including red days, which is more than most channels show.
What you can't check: The reports are daily totals, not a trade-by-trade log, so you cannot see which signals hit the stop loss or how big each loss was. Marketing such as "100% TP/SL accuracy" and a $2,397 plan sold with "near-guaranteed" calls pull the score down.
Read our full RAVEN Signals Pro review.
6. Evening Trader
How results are shown: The group run by the NFTevening news site posts weekly wrap-ups with a win rate, and it has reported at least one losing trade in the open. Signals come with an entry zone, targets and a stop loss.
What the numbers say: One weekly wrap-up showed a 67.5% win rate, a believable number.
What you can't check: The NFTevening page promotes "90%+ winrate" signals, which does not match the group's own weekly figure, and ROI totals add up leveraged trades. There is no full trade history.
Read our full Evening Trader review.
7. Oldman Crypto
How results are shown: Oldman Crypto calls itself a personal trading journal of "entries, exits, wins, and losses" and posts scorecards of its calls. Its full setups include a stop loss.
What the numbers say: The scorecards are regular and the channel does not push exchange sign-ups.
What you can't check: Many posts are short "buy at" calls without a stop, the scorecards mostly show winners, and there is no complete trade history to check them against.
Read our full Oldman Crypto review.
8. Fat Pig Signals
How results are shown: Fat Pig Signals has a long public archive of monthly results images, and unlike most channels, those images include the losing trades.
What the numbers say: The archive goes back years, which makes it one of the longest public histories we found.
What you can't check: The results are measured at the best price each trade reached, not where traders actually got out, so they look better than real trading. The free signals come without a stop loss.
Read our full Fat Pig Signals review.
Why Only Nine Channels?
We set out to list ten. Only nine, ours included, showed any losing trades in public, and that was our minimum to be on this list. Big names such as WolfX Signals, Whales Crypto Guide and Wallstreet Queen are not here because we could not find their losses anywhere. We will add channels to this list when they start publishing records that can be checked.
Checked, But Not Listed
| Channel | Why it is not listed |
|---|---|
| WolfX Signals | Its "verified" record is a forex account with no public link, and its crypto results are not published in a way we could check. |
| Whales Crypto Guide | Results posts only show targets being hit, and there is no track record. |
| Wallstreet Queen Official | Every results post we saw was a win, and there is no track record. |
| Learn2Trade | The channel only posts winning updates, and we found no track record for its crypto signals. |
| CryptoSignals.org | We found no public record of past signals with losses. |
| Fed. Russian Insiders | High accuracy claims with no record that shows losing trades. |
How to Check Any Signals Channel Yourself
- Ask for the full record. Not the best month, every trade. If there is no log with losses, the win rate is a claim, not a fact.
- Look for live replies. Results posted as replies under the original signal, with timestamps, are hard to fake. A monthly image is easy to edit.
- Check the stop loss. Every signal should have one written down before the trade, not added later.
- Read how a win is counted. "Target 1 hit" is not a win if the trade then hits the stop loss. Ask which target counts.
- Watch the free channel for a week. Compare what is posted there with the numbers on the website.
- Be careful with totals. Adding up leveraged percentages, like "+2,000% this month", tells you nothing about what a real account made.
Red Flags of a Crypto Signal Scam
- "100% accurate", "guaranteed" or "no losing trades" in the marketing
- Win rates above 90% with no full trade history behind them
- Only profit screenshots, never a stop loss hit
- Countdown discounts that end in a few hours, every week
- Payment to a private wallet with no refund policy
- Requests for your exchange login or an API key with withdrawal rights
See our full ranking of the best crypto signals Telegram channels and the best crypto signals Discord servers, scored with the same kind of checks.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are crypto signals legit?
Some are, many are not. A legit crypto signals channel gives a stop loss on every signal and shows its losing trades, ideally in a record you can check trade by trade. If a channel only ever posts wins, treat its accuracy claims as marketing.
What are the most accurate crypto signals?
No signal provider is accurate all the time. The most reliable ones are not the ones with the highest claimed win rate, but the ones whose results you can verify. A checked 55% win rate with stop losses is worth more than an unproven "95%".
Are there 100% accurate crypto signals?
No. Every real trading record has losing trades. Any channel that promises 100% accurate or guaranteed signals is either hiding its losses or not telling the truth, and that is one of the clearest signs of a crypto signal scam.
How can I verify a crypto signals channel?
Ask for a full results log with losses, check that each result is posted as a reply to the original signal with a timestamp, compare the free channel with the claims on the website, and look for edits. Live tracking by a bot such as Cornix is much harder to fake than a monthly image.
What is a live track record?
A live track record shows each result at the moment it happens, for example a bot replying "Target 3 hit" or "Stop loss hit" under the original signal. A monthly report is typed up after the fact, so it can leave trades out.
Is a high win rate a good sign?
Not on its own. Check how the channel defines a win. Some count a trade as a win if the first target is hit, even if it then hits the stop loss. At Bullstar Signals a trade only counts as a win at Target 3 or higher.
What does breakeven mean in a signal result?
It means the stop loss was moved to the entry price after a target was hit, and the trade then closed at that entry for roughly 0%. Honest channels list these trades separately instead of counting them as wins.
How do I spot a crypto signal scam?
Common red flags are "guaranteed" profits, win rates above 90% with no record, only winning screenshots, pressure to pay within hours, and requests to send money to a private wallet or to give someone access to your exchange account.
Are free crypto signals on Telegram reliable?
Some are. A free channel is the best way to test a provider before paying, as long as its free signals include an entry, targets and a stop loss. Our free Bullstar Signals channel posts full signals so you can check them yourself.
Is this list financial advice?
No. This list compares how transparent each channel is about its results. It is not financial advice, and trading crypto futures with leverage can lose you money quickly.
Final Thoughts
Transparency does not guarantee profits, and no channel on this list wins every trade, ours included. But a provider that shows its losses, live and in public, is giving you what you need to judge it. A provider that only shows wins is asking you to trust it blindly. Start with a free channel, check the record against the signals, and only then decide if a VIP plan is worth it.
Not financial advice. Crypto trading, especially futures with leverage, carries a high risk of loss. Only trade with money you can afford to lose.