BULLSTAR 
Evening Trader is the Telegram trading group of NFTevening, a well-known crypto news website. Its free group has around 13,700 subscribers, and its VIP is promoted with "90%+ winrate" signals, daily market updates and 1-on-1 support. So is Evening Trader legit, and do the numbers hold up?
We checked the official links on the NFTevening website, the free Telegram group and its posts, and compared the claims with what you can verify. This review covers how the signals work, what the results posts show, what VIP costs and how you pay.
This review is written by the Bullstar Signals team. We run a competing signals service, so we have a bias, and we want you to know that up front. Everything below is based on what anyone can see on the Evening Trader public Telegram channel in October 2026. We don't claim anything we can't point to, and we suggest you check every point yourself.
Backed by a known crypto media brand, with complete signals that include a stop loss, and at least one losing trade reported openly. But the "90%+ winrate" on the website doesn't match the channel's own 67.5% weekly figure, results are summed into huge ROI numbers, VIP is paid by sending crypto to wallet addresses with no refund policy we could find, and Telegram's public preview of the group is turned off.
Evening Trader at a Glance
| Evening Trader | |
|---|---|
| Free group | @EveningTrader, about 13.7K subscribers |
| Backed by | NFTevening (crypto news website) |
| Support | @Eveningtradersupport |
| Style | Mostly leveraged altcoin scalps, 10x to 12x |
| Signal format | Entry zone, several targets and a stop loss |
| VIP price | $79 (10 days), $129 (1 month), $499 (1 year), $899 (lifetime), often discounted |
| Payment | Crypto sent to wallet addresses, via support |
| Refunds | No policy found |
| Transparency Score | 5.8/10 |
What Is Evening Trader?
Evening Trader describes itself as "a Telegram trading group backed by NFTevening". NFTevening is a crypto news and education website, and its trading community page links to the official group, @EveningTrader, and to the support account @Eveningtradersupport. The group's description also links to a bot for "VIP and Whale rooms" and an X account.
The website promotes the VIP with "latest market signals with 90%+ winrate", "25+ signals/week", daily and weekly market breakdowns, 1-on-1 support, airdrop alerts and trading competitions.
One practical note: Telegram's public web preview is turned off for this group, so you can't read its posts on the web before joining. We reviewed the posts through TGStat, a Telegram analytics site, and the most recent posts available there were from late March 2026. Join through the link on nftevening.com and check the latest posts yourself before paying.
How Evening Trader Signals Work
The signals we saw were complete. A "Scalp Short" on MIRA used 10x leverage, with an entry zone, a stop loss and four take-profit targets. A "Scalp Long" on ALGO used 12x leverage, with an entry zone, five targets and a stop loss. Each listed the exchanges where the pair is available. That's a full trade plan, and the stop loss is a good sign. Our guide to reading a signal explains each part.
The leverage is what to watch. At 10x to 12x, a move of around 8% to 10% against you can wipe out an isolated position, and scalps move fast. If you follow these signals, check that your liquidation price is well beyond the stop loss. Our liquidation guide shows how.
What the Results Posts Show
This is where Evening Trader is more open than many channels, at least partly. Alongside "done Full TP" posts, we saw an update saying an ALGO trade hit the second entry and was "closed soon -31%". Posting a loss like that is a good sign. Other updates moved the stop loss to break-even after a target was hit.
The weekly summaries are a different story. A "Week 44 ROI Wrap-Up" listed a win rate of 67.50%, a "Total ROI Private" of +1,828.78%, and key wins like +250% and +203.70%. Two problems:
- The win rate doesn't match the website. The channel's own weekly figure was 67.5%, while the NFTevening page promotes "90%+ winrate" signals.
- The ROI is a sum of leveraged percentages. Adding up the percentage gain of every trade, each multiplied by 10x or more, gives a number no real account would make. Our leverage guide explains why.
We also didn't find a trade-by-trade record you can check. The weekly posts list the key wins, not every trade with its result.
A 67.5% win rate can be profitable or losing, depending on how big the losses are compared with the wins. Without every trade listed, you can't tell. Read more in why Telegram signal channels hide their losses.
Evening Trader VIP: Price and Payment
The VIP prices posted in the group were $79 for 10 days, $129 for 1 month, $499 for 1 year and $899 for lifetime access. A limited-time offer cut these to 47, 77, 299 and 539 USDT. Discounts like this are common, but "grab your spot" offers are also a classic pressure tactic, so don't let a deadline rush you.
How you pay matters more. The offer listed crypto wallet addresses on three networks (BEP-20, Solana and Tron) and asked members to contact support to join. We found no refund policy.
- Crypto payments cannot be reversed. Once you send, there is no chargeback.
- Only pay to addresses from the official group or support account linked on nftevening.com. The group itself warned that another channel was copying its screenshots, so copycats are a real risk. Read how to spot a fake crypto signals channel.
- Start with the shortest plan and track every signal before paying for a year or lifetime. Our VIP crypto signals guide lists more questions to ask.
The group also promotes trading competitions and fee discounts on BingX through a referral code. Referral programs usually pay the promoter a share of trading fees, which is common but worth knowing.
Transparency Score: How Evening Trader Scores
We score every channel on the same six public criteria we used in our ranking of the best crypto signals Telegram groups. Each one scores 2 points (yes), 1 point (partly) or 0 points (not seen or not verifiable), and the total out of 12 is converted to a score out of 10.
| Criterion | Result | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Stop loss on signals | ✓ Entry zone, targets and stop loss on the signals we saw | 2 |
| Losses shown publicly | ~ At least one loss reported openly, but weekly posts focus on wins | 1 |
| Full public track record | ✗ Weekly summaries only, no trade-by-trade record | 0 |
| Independently verified | ✗ No third-party audit | 0 |
| Free channel to test | ✓ Free group to join (web preview turned off) | 2 |
| Trade in your own account | ✓ Yes, any exchange you like | 2 |
| Total | 7 of 12 | 5.8/10 |
That score places Evening Trader between WolfX Signals (6.7) and Whales Crypto Guide (5.0) in our full ranking.
Pros and Cons of Evening Trader
- Backed by a known crypto media brand
- Complete signals with a stop loss
- At least one losing trade reported openly
- Stop loss moved to break-even after targets
- Weekly summaries with a win rate
- Trade on any exchange in your own account
- "90%+ winrate" claim doesn't match the channel's 67.5% weekly figure
- ROI numbers add up leveraged percentages
- No trade-by-trade track record
- VIP paid by sending crypto to wallet addresses, no refund policy found
- High leverage scalps, 10x to 12x
- Public web preview turned off, harder to check before joining
Is Evening Trader Legit or a Scam?
Based on what we could see, Evening Trader is a real group, officially linked from the NFTevening website, with complete signals and at least some honesty about losing trades. We found no evidence that it takes money and disappears.
The concerns are about how results are presented and how you pay. The win rate on the website and in the channel don't match, the ROI totals are inflated by adding leveraged trades together, and VIP is paid directly in crypto with no refund policy. So the answer is: a real group with a media brand behind it, but its headline numbers don't add up. Join the free group, check how active it is today, and track the signals yourself before you send any crypto.
Evening Trader vs Bullstar Signals
Since we run a competing service, here is a straight comparison. Check both and decide for yourself.
| Evening Trader | Bullstar Signals | |
|---|---|---|
| Stop loss on signals | ✓ On the signals we saw | ✓ On every signal |
| Losses published | ~ Some, not systematically | ✓ Every closed signal, one by one |
| Full public track record | ✗ Weekly summaries only | ✓ Yes, since 2022, on our results page |
| Price | $129/month list price, often discounted | From $49/month, $199 lifetime |
| When a trade counts as a win | Not stated (weekly win rate given) | Only at Target 3 or higher |
| Free channel | @EveningTrader (about 13.7K) | Bullstar Signals (79.5K+) |
Evening Trader has a media brand behind it and reports some losses. The biggest differences are the public trade-by-trade record and how the results are counted. At Bullstar Signals, every closed VIP signal since 2022 is listed publicly, stop losses included, and a trade only counts as a win once it reaches Target 3. Our record is published by us and not audited by a third party, so check it yourself the same way you'd check anyone else's.
Follow our free Telegram channel for a few weeks, compare the signals with our public results, and only upgrade if the numbers convince you.
Join Bullstar Signals free channelWho Is Evening Trader Best For?
- A good fit if you're an experienced scalper comfortable with 10x to 12x leverage, and you like having market news and airdrop alerts in the same place.
- Think twice if you're new to futures, want a verifiable track record, or aren't comfortable paying by sending crypto to a wallet address.
- Whatever you choose, use a stop loss on every trade and risk only a small part of your account per signal. Our 5 risk management rules are a good place to start.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Evening Trader legit?
Evening Trader is a real Telegram group officially linked from the NFTevening website, and its signals include a stop loss. However, its "90%+ winrate" claim doesn't match the 67.5% weekly win rate posted in the group, there's no trade-by-trade record, and VIP is paid directly in crypto with no refund policy we could find.
How much does Evening Trader VIP cost?
Prices posted in the group were $79 for 10 days, $129 for 1 month, $499 for 1 year and $899 for lifetime access, with limited-time discounts to 47, 77, 299 and 539 USDT. Payment is made in crypto to wallet addresses, arranged through @Eveningtradersupport.
Who owns Evening Trader?
The group describes itself as backed by NFTevening, a crypto news and education website. The official link to the group is on the NFTevening trading community page.
Does Evening Trader use stop losses?
Yes. The signals we reviewed, such as a MIRA short and an ALGO long, included an entry zone, several targets and a stop loss. They also used 10x to 12x leverage, so size your positions carefully.
Why can't I see Evening Trader posts on the web?
Telegram's public web preview is turned off for the group, so you need to join it in the Telegram app to read the posts. Join only through the link on nftevening.com to avoid copycat groups.
What is a good alternative to Evening Trader?
If you want every closed signal published one by one, losses included, Bullstar Signals lists every closed VIP signal since 2022, with plans from $49 a month. You can test it in our free channel first.
Final Thoughts
Evening Trader has things many channels don't: a media brand behind it, complete signals with a stop loss, and at least one loss reported in the open. But a 90% claim next to a 67.5% weekly figure, ROI totals built from leveraged trades, and crypto-only payments without a refund policy are reasons to check carefully before you pay.
Our advice is the same for every signals group, including ours: test the free channel, track the results yourself, and never trust a win rate you can't check. To compare Evening Trader with the other well-known channels we scored, see our full ranking of the best crypto signals Telegram groups, or read our reviews of Binance Killers and RAVEN Signals Pro.
Disclaimer: This review is for information only and is not financial advice. Details are based on the Evening Trader public Telegram channel in October 2026 and may change. Crypto trading, especially with leverage, carries a high risk of loss.