BULLSTAR 
Last updated: October 29, 2026
Evening Trader is the Telegram trading group of NFTevening, a well-known crypto news site. Its signals are complete, with an entry zone, several targets and a stop loss, and it has reported at least one losing trade in the open. But the "90%+ winrate" on the website doesn't match the group's own 67.5% weekly figure, the ROI totals add up leveraged trades, and VIP is paid by sending crypto to a wallet with no refund policy we could find.
If you want signals with numbers you can actually check, there are other options. We compared Evening Trader with six signal groups using the same transparency checks we use in all our reviews. Bullstar Signals is our own channel and it is on this list, so we say that clearly and give you the numbers and links to check everything yourself.
- Every trade listed, losses included: Bullstar Signals (our channel) and AltSignals.
- A refund window: AltSignals, 24 hours.
- Weekly loss reports: RAVEN Signals Pro.
- Daily market updates and lessons: Binance Killers.
- A full month of results on one image: Fat Pig Signals.
Why Traders Look for Evening Trader Alternatives
Evening Trader gets some things right, and we covered it in detail in our Evening Trader review. These are the things that make traders look elsewhere:
- Win rates that don't match. The NFTevening page promotes "90%+ winrate" signals, while the group's own weekly wrap-up showed 67.5%.
- Inflated ROI totals. Weekly posts add up the leveraged gain of every trade into numbers like +1,828%, which no real account would make.
- No trade-by-trade record. The weekly posts list key wins, not every trade with its result.
- Crypto payments, no refunds. VIP is paid by sending USDT to wallet addresses, and crypto payments can't be reversed.
- High leverage scalps. Most signals use 10x to 12x, which leaves little room for mistakes.
How We Compared Them
Every channel here was scored on the same six checks we use in our ranking of the best crypto signals Telegram groups: a stop loss on signals, losses shown publicly, a full public track record, independent verification, a free channel you can test, and trading in your own exchange account. Yes is worth 2 points, partly 1 and no 0, and the total is scaled to 10.
| Channel | Score | VIP price | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bullstar Signals (ours) Join free → | 9.2/10 | $49/month, $199 lifetime | Every closed signal, wins only at Target 3 |
| RAVEN Signals Pro View → | 7.5/10 | $99/month, $299/year | Weekly reports with losses, Cornix |
| AltSignals View → | 7.5/10 | $70/month per service | Monthly trade lists, 24h refund |
| Binance Killers View → | 6.7/10 | $249/month, $749 lifetime | Daily crypto updates and trading lessons |
| WolfX Signals View → | 6.7/10 | $89/month, $279 lifetime | Large channel, crypto plus gold |
| Fat Pig Signals View → | 6.7/10 | 0.50 ETH for 3 months | Full monthly results with losses |
| Evening Trader View → | 5.8/10 | $129/month, $899 lifetime | Leveraged altcoin scalps |
Prices are from each channel's plans page as listed in our reviews in October 2026. Sales and discounts change them often, so always check the current price before you pay.
6 Evening Trader Alternatives Worth Checking
1. Bullstar Signals (our channel)
Crypto futures signals on coins listed on Binance Futures, each with an entry zone, several targets and a stop loss. Every closed VIP signal since 2022 is listed one by one on our results page, losing trades included, and a trade only counts as a win when it reaches Target 3 or higher.
Why it is an alternative: a record you can check trade by trade instead of a weekly ROI total, and a clear rule for what counts as a win. VIP starts at $49 per month, against $129 for Evening Trader.
What to keep in mind: we only do crypto futures, and our record is published by us, not audited by an independent third party. Follow the free channel and check the results yourself before you join VIP.
2. RAVEN Signals Pro
Crypto and forex signals with entry zones, several take-profit levels and a stop loss. RAVEN posts weekly performance reports that include losing trades, and VIP members can automate the signals with Cornix.
Why it is an alternative: losses are reported every week, so you see the bad weeks too, not just the key wins.
What to keep in mind: the reports show weekly totals, not a trade-by-trade log, and the prices on their FAQ and services page don't match. Read our RAVEN Signals Pro review.
3. AltSignals
Running since 2017, with separate services for low and high leverage futures, spot swings, forex and AI signals. Each month AltSignals publishes a report listing every trade, losing trades and losing months included.
Why it is an alternative: a full monthly trade list instead of summed ROI, a low leverage service if 10x scalps feel too risky, and a 24-hour money-back guarantee.
What to keep in mind: each service is a separate subscription, and the free channel mostly posts target updates, not full signals to test. Read our AltSignals review.
4. Binance Killers
One of the largest crypto-only signal communities on Telegram. Signals come with several targets and a stop loss, and the community shares daily market updates, lessons and trading tips.
Why it is an alternative: if you like Evening Trader for its market breakdowns, Binance Killers offers the same mix of signals and daily crypto updates, and its monthly summaries mention losing trades.
What to keep in mind: it is the most expensive option at $249 per month, the free channel posts signal numbers rather than full signals, and we found no complete public trade history. Read our Binance Killers review.
5. WolfX Signals
A very large service with around 153,000 people in its free channel. Its VIP signals come with an entry, three targets and a stop loss, cover crypto, forex and gold, and can be automated with Cornix.
Why it is an alternative: complete signals and a long history, with a crypto VIP that costs less per month than Evening Trader.
What to keep in mind: the free channel posts mostly gold and forex, its big "verified" record is a forex account you can't open, and all sales are final. Read our WolfX Signals review.
6. Fat Pig Signals
Running since 2017, according to its website. Its monthly results images list every trade of the month, losing trades included, and the archive goes back years.
Why it is an alternative: a full month of trades with the losses on it, instead of a weekly list of key wins.
What to keep in mind: we saw no stop loss in the free channel signals, results measure the maximum move rather than real exits, and like Evening Trader, VIP is paid in crypto only. Read our Fat Pig Signals review.
Price Comparison
Evening Trader VIP is listed at $79 for 10 days, $129 per month, $499 per year or $899 lifetime, often discounted, and paid in crypto with no refund policy we could find. Here is how the alternatives compare:
- Bullstar Signals: $49 per month, $199 lifetime.
- AltSignals: about $70 per month for each service, 24-hour refund.
- WolfX Signals: $89 per month, $279 lifetime, all sales final.
- RAVEN Signals Pro: $99 per month, $299 per year.
- Binance Killers: $249 per month, $749 lifetime.
- Fat Pig Signals: 0.50 ETH for 3 months.
Whatever you pay, start with the shortest plan. A lifetime deal is only good value if the signals work for you.
How to Test Any Signal Group Before You Pay
- Follow the free channel for two weeks. Write down every signal, wins and losses, and work out your own win rate.
- Compare claims with posts. If the website says 90% and the channel says 67.5%, trust the lower number until you can check it.
- Ignore summed ROI. Adding leveraged percentages together says nothing about a real account. Our guide to hidden losses explains what to look for instead.
- Be careful with crypto payments. Only pay to addresses from the official group, and read how to spot a fake signals channel first.
- Lower the leverage. You can follow a 10x signal with 3x and a smaller position. Our position size calculator helps you size each trade.
Which Alternative Should You Choose?
- You want every trade, losses included: Bullstar Signals or AltSignals.
- You want a refund window: AltSignals.
- You want signals plus daily market news: Binance Killers.
- You want crypto and forex in one place: RAVEN Signals Pro or WolfX Signals.
- You want a low monthly price: Bullstar Signals.
If you want to try ours, the free Bullstar Telegram channel lets you watch our setups live, and the results page shows every VIP signal, losses included. Compare it with any group on this list before you decide.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best alternative to Evening Trader?
If you want to check every trade, Bullstar Signals and AltSignals publish their full results, losses included. If you want a refund window, AltSignals offers 24 hours. RAVEN Signals Pro reports its losses every week.
Is Evening Trader legit?
It is a real group linked from the NFTevening website, and its signals include a stop loss. But its "90%+ winrate" claim doesn't match the 67.5% weekly win rate posted in the group, there is no trade-by-trade record, and VIP is paid in crypto with no refund policy we could find.
How much does Evening Trader VIP cost?
Prices posted in the group were $79 for 10 days, $129 for 1 month, $499 for 1 year and $899 lifetime, often discounted, paid in crypto through the support account.
Is Evening Trader's 90% win rate real?
We couldn't confirm it. The group's own weekly wrap-up showed a 67.5% win rate, and the ROI totals add up leveraged percentages from many trades, which no real account would earn.
Which Evening Trader alternative has a refund?
AltSignals offers a 24-hour money-back guarantee. Evening Trader has no refund policy we could find, and WolfX Signals says all sales are final.
Which alternative uses lower leverage than Evening Trader?
Evening Trader scalps mostly use 10x to 12x. AltSignals has a separate low leverage futures service, and with any group you can trade the same signal with lower leverage and a smaller position.
Which alternative is best for daily market updates?
Binance Killers posts daily crypto market updates and trading lessons in its community, close to what Evening Trader offers with its market breakdowns.
Can I pay for crypto signals by card?
It depends on the group. Many Telegram groups, including Evening Trader and Fat Pig Signals, take crypto only, and crypto payments can't be reversed. Check the payment method and refund terms before you subscribe.
Is Bullstar Signals an independent reviewer?
No. Bullstar Signals is our own channel. We scored it with the same checks as every other channel, and our results page lets you check the record yourself instead of taking our word for it.
Not financial advice. Crypto trading, especially with leverage, carries a high risk of loss. Bullstar Signals is our own service. We are not affiliated with Evening Trader, NFTevening or any other channel on this list.