Rose is one of the better-known crypto trading channels on Telegram, with about 84,800 subscribers at @rose. The bio warns about "Fake Roses" and impersonators, names a support admin and links to a second channel with a "collection of setups". So is Rose legit, and are its calls worth following?
We read every public post in the channel from October 7 to November 16, 2026, 129 posts in total, and checked what each one gave you to trade with. This review covers what the channel posts, how its October calls played out, how it makes money, its link to the Binance Signals channel, how it scores on our six transparency points and which channels to look at instead.
This review is written by the Bullstar Signals team. We run a competing signals service, so we have a bias, and we want you to know that up front. Everything below is based on what anyone can see in the Rose public Telegram channel. Check every point yourself.
A popular, free channel of chart ideas and market opinions, mostly on small-cap coins. It never posts an entry, a target and a stop loss together, never posts results, and earns from exchange referral links rather than a paid group. It is a feed of ideas, not a signals service.
Rose at a Glance
| Details | |
|---|---|
| Telegram | Rose on Telegram |
| Subscribers | About 84,800 |
| Typical views per post | About 15,800 |
| Posts per day | About 3 |
| Paid plan | None seen |
| Stop loss on calls | None seen |
| Results posted | None |
| Transparency Score | 2.5/10 (Risky) |
What Is Rose?
Rose posts short chart ideas, mostly a coin ticker with a chart and a few words: "#ZEC time.", "#INJ is new NEAR", "#PEPE BULLRUN gets started." The channel also comments on Bitcoin cycles, whale positions and liquidation levels. The support admin listed in the bio is @cookingfood, and a second channel, RoseStreetTradingCollection, collects older setups.
There are other channels using the Rose name, and the bio itself warns about impersonators. This review covers only @rose.
What the Free Channel Actually Posts
We sorted the 129 posts from October 7 to November 16 by what they contained:
| Posts that included... | Count | Share |
|---|---|---|
| A chart image | 109 | 84% |
| A coin ticker such as #ZEC or #PEPE | 71 | 55% |
| Comments on Bitcoin | 20 | 16% |
| An entry or "buy" level | 2 | 2% |
| A stop loss | 0 | 0% |
| A result with a profit or loss figure | 0 | 0% |
The 71 ticker posts covered 38 different coins. Most read as bullish ideas, with phrases like "new leg", "breakout" or "is next". The charts are clean and some of the market notes are sharp, but none of the posts tells you where to enter, where to take profit and where the idea is wrong.
How the October Calls Played Out
Rose was clearly bullish going into October. On October 9 and again on October 11 the channel posted "The main part of October is UP", on October 13 "October Breakout" and on October 14 "Bullrun will get started at October or something".
The market went the other way. By November the tone had changed to "we are F.", "Max pain 1: 60k, Max pain 2: below 40k" and "Buy at Mid-Late December." Every analyst gets calls wrong. The issue is that the channel never comes back to say which ideas worked and which didn't, so a reader has no way to judge its overall record.
Rose and the Binance Signals channel (@binancesignals) appear to share the same admin. In our sample, several posts appeared in both channels within a day of each other with the same wording, such as "#EVAA is next AKE", "#SPACE Any correlation with Elon Musk?" and "Price grinding down, OI grinding up, very hard mode for BULLs", and the Binance Signals admin refers to themselves as Rose. See our Binance Signals review.
Members and Views
Posts get about 15,800 views each, around 19% of subscribers, with a range from about 4,100 to 23,000. That is a healthy, real-looking audience for a channel this size.
How Rose Makes Money
We saw no paid VIP group and no price. On November 13 the channel posted a Bybit "World Series of Trading" team invite with a referral link, promising rewards of up to 10M USDT across the competition. The linked Binance Signals channel runs an exchange cashback program.
Referral income is normal, but it is worth knowing. A channel paid through exchange referrals earns more when its followers trade more, whether they win or lose. Trading competitions in particular push people toward bigger and more frequent trades.
Transparency Score: How Rose Scores
We score every channel on the same six public criteria we use in our ranking of the best crypto signals Telegram groups. Each one scores 2 points (yes), 1 point (partly) or 0 points (not seen or not verifiable), and the total out of 12 is turned into a score out of 10.
| Criterion | What we found | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Stop loss on signals | ✗ No stop loss in any post we read | 0 |
| Losses shown publicly | ✗ No results, wins or losses, are posted | 0 |
| Full public track record | ✗ No record of past calls and their outcomes | 0 |
| Independently verified | ✗ No verified account, copy-trading profile or audit | 0 |
| Free channel to test | ~ Everything is free and live, but posts are chart ideas without entries, targets or stops | 1 |
| Trade in your own account | ✓ Ideas are traded on your own exchange | 2 |
| Total | 3 of 12 points | 2.5/10 |
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Free, with no paid group pushed | No stop loss, entry or target on calls |
| Clean charts and some sharp market notes | No results or record of past calls |
| Real, active audience with about 19% views per post | October bullish calls were not revisited |
| Warns readers about impersonators | Earns from exchange referrals and trading competitions |
Is Rose Legit or a Scam?
We can't call Rose a scam. It is free, it doesn't sell a VIP group, and its audience looks real. But it is not a signals service you can measure. Posts are short ideas without the details you need to trade them, there are no results, and the main income comes from exchange referrals. Treat it as one opinion among many, not as calls to copy.
Rose vs Bullstar Signals
| Rose | Bullstar Signals | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry and targets | Rarely | On every signal |
| Stop loss on signals | None seen | On every signal |
| Losses posted | None | Every stop loss on the public results page |
| Track record | None | Every closed VIP signal since 2022 |
| Price | Free, earns from exchange referrals | Listed on the website |
We are biased here, so compare for yourself: our results page lists every VIP signal since 2022 with the losses in it, and our free Telegram channel is open to anyone.
Best Rose Alternatives
If you want a signals group where you can check more before paying, these channels scored higher on the same six points. Tap a name for our full review.
1. Bullstar Signals (9.2/10)
Our own channel. Every closed VIP signal since 2022 is on a public results page, stop losses included, and every signal has an entry zone, targets and a stop loss.
2. RAVEN Signals Pro (7.5/10)
Crypto and forex signals with a stop loss on every call and weekly reports that include losing days.
3. AltSignals (7.5/10)
A long-running group with a public results page and stop losses on its calls, though the free channel shows few full signals.
4. Binance Killers (6.7/10)
One of the largest channels on Telegram. Calls come with a stop loss and losses are posted, but there is no full record to check.
5. Fat Pig Signals (6.7/10)
Posts monthly summaries with win and loss counts, though stop losses were not on every call we saw.
You can compare every channel side by side in our best crypto signals Telegram groups ranking.
Who Is Rose For?
If you already trade on your own and like reading chart ideas on small-cap coins, Rose can give you coins to research. If you want complete signals with a stop loss, or a record you can check before trusting someone's calls, it is not a good fit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Rose Telegram channel legit?
It is a real, popular channel with about 85K subscribers and an active audience, and it does not sell a paid group. But its posts are chart ideas without entries, targets or stop losses, and it never posts results. It scores 2.5 out of 10 on our transparency points.
Is Rose free?
Yes. We saw no paid plan. The channel earns from exchange referral links, such as a Bybit trading competition team invite.
Does Rose use stop losses?
No. In 129 posts we did not see a single stop loss, and only two posts gave any kind of buy level.
Are Rose and Binance Signals the same?
They appear to share an admin. Several posts appeared in both channels within a day of each other with the same wording, and the Binance Signals admin calls themselves Rose.
What are the best Rose alternatives?
Channels that post complete signals and show their results, such as Bullstar Signals, RAVEN Signals Pro and AltSignals, which include stop losses and publish losing trades too.
What is the official Rose Telegram?
The channel reviewed here is @rose, with @cookingfood listed as support admin in the bio. The channel warns about impersonators, so never send funds to anyone who messages you first.
Final Thoughts
Rose is a well-known name with a real following and some good charts, but it is an idea feed, not a signals service. Before you follow any signals group, look for three things: complete signals with a stop loss, losses posted next to the wins, and a record you can check. Rose shows none of them in public.
This review is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto trading, especially with leverage, carries a high risk of loss.

