Coin Signals is a large crypto signals channel on Telegram, with about 71,400 subscribers. Its bio promises free crypto signals, daily market updates, auto trading and "10x gems", and it sells a VIP service through a private chat. So is Coin Signals legit, and is the VIP worth paying for?
We read every public post in the channel from October 7 to November 16, 2026, 145 posts in total, and checked each signal and each result against what anyone can see. This review covers what the channel posts, how its signals are built, what the results posts really show, how it scores on our six transparency points and which channels to look at instead.
This review is written by the Bullstar Signals team. We run a competing signals service, so we have a bias, and we want you to know that up front. Everything below is based on what anyone can see in the Coin Signals public Telegram channel. Check every point yourself.
A real, active channel with a big audience and well-built signals that always include a stop loss. The free channel shares VIP signals as proof, forwarded together with their results once they hit their targets. That shows the signals were real, but only the winners are shared, and not one losing trade was shown.
Coin Signals at a Glance
| Details | |
|---|---|
| Telegram | Coin Signals on Telegram |
| Subscribers | About 71,400 |
| Typical views per post | About 10,900 |
| VIP access | Private chat with @Last_Satoshi or the @Vip_CoinSignals_bot |
| Price | $365 a year (limited offer), normally $500 a year |
| Stop loss on signals | Yes, on every signal we saw |
| Losses posted | None seen |
| Transparency Score | 4.2/10 (Risky) |
What Is Coin Signals?
Coin Signals describes itself as "a group of expert traders and analysts". The free channel mixes three things: market commentary on Bitcoin, Ethereum and gold, futures signals forwarded from the VIP channel, and result posts showing VIP trades that hit their targets. The bio also says the team does not offer fund management, which is a good sign. Anyone who offers to trade your money for you is a red flag.
The audience looks real. Posts get about 10,900 views each, around 15% of subscribers, which is healthy for a channel this size. That is much better than many large channels we have reviewed, where views are a tiny share of the member count.
What the Free Channel Actually Posts
We sorted the 145 posts from the last 40 days by what they contained:
| Posts that included... | Count | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Market commentary, charts and news | About 70 | 48% |
| A "take-profit" or "all targets achieved" result | 56 | 39% |
| A full signal with entry, targets and stop loss | 9 | 6% |
| A VIP offer or monthly VIP results | 4 | 3% |
| A stop loss or losing trade | 0 | 0% |
28 of the 145 posts were copies of an earlier post. The market commentary is short and readable, with clear levels to watch on Bitcoin and Ethereum.
How Coin Signals Builds Its Signals
The signals themselves are well structured. Every one of the 9 signal posts we saw had an entry zone, four take-profit targets, a stop loss and a suggested leverage between 10x and 20x. All of them were shorts on BTC, ETH, BNB, HYPE or gold, which fits the falling market of the last few weeks.
Two things are worth knowing before you copy them:
- The stop losses are wide for the leverage. Measured from the first entry price, the stop loss sits 2.5% to 6.8% away. At the suggested 10x to 20x leverage, hitting it would cost between 35% and 71% of the margin on that trade. Most traders would size down a lot or use lower leverage.
- The profits are leveraged. "Profit: 120%" means the price moved about 12% at 10x leverage, or 6% at 20x. That is a good trade, but it is not a 120% move.
We also saw a few short "shorted here" posts, for example a short on LIT with a target but no stop loss. These are informal calls, not full signals.
The full signals in the free channel are proof posts, not live calls. When a VIP signal hits its targets, the channel forwards the original signal together with its result, for example a short on ETH posted next to "All targets achieved, Profit: 120%, Period: 3 days". All 9 signals in our sample were shared this way, between 9 hours and 1 month and 18 days after the trade started. This is a fair way to show that a signal really existed before the move. But it means the free channel only shows trades that won, and you never get a live signal to test before paying.
Profit Claims vs What You Can Check
The result posts look like this: "#BTC/USDT All targets achieved. Profit: 120%. Period: 1 day 11 hr." In our sample there were 56 of them, with profits from 15% to 200%. There was not a single post about a stop loss being hit.
The monthly VIP results follow the same pattern. A post for July claimed "Signal Gains: 1243%" and one for September claimed 1180%, with no losing trades listed and no way to see the trades behind the number.
Forwarding the original signal is better than a bare profit screenshot, because you can see the entry, targets and stop loss were set before the move. But because only the winning signals are forwarded, you can't use the free channel to judge the VIP. You see the winners, but you don't see how many VIP signals were stopped out in the same period. Every signal group has losing trades. A channel that only ever shows wins is showing you a selection, not a record.
Coin Signals Price
The pinned post offers a yearly VIP plan for $365, described as a limited offer before the price goes up to $500 a year. To join, you message @Last_Satoshi or use the @Vip_CoinSignals_bot. We found no monthly price, no refund policy and no trial of live VIP signals.
Be careful with private messages. Big channels attract impersonators who copy the name and photo of the admin. Only message the exact username written in the channel bio, and never send funds to someone who contacts you first.
Transparency Score: How Coin Signals Scores
We score every channel on the same six public criteria we use in our ranking of the best crypto signals Telegram groups. Each one scores 2 points (yes), 1 point (partly) or 0 points (not seen or not verifiable), and the total out of 12 is turned into a score out of 10.
| Criterion | What we found | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Stop loss on signals | ✓ Every signal posted in the free channel had a stop loss | 2 |
| Losses shown publicly | ✗ No stop loss or losing trade posted in 145 posts; monthly results show gains only | 0 |
| Full public track record | ✗ No public record of every VIP signal, wins and losses | 0 |
| Independently verified | ✗ No verified account, copy-trading profile or audit | 0 |
| Free channel to test | ~ Free channel is open, but full signals are shared only as proof after they hit their targets | 1 |
| Trade in your own account | ✓ Signals are copied on your own exchange | 2 |
| Total | 5 of 12 points | 4.2/10 |
Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Every signal has entry, four targets and a stop loss | Free channel shares signals only as proof, after they win |
| Real, active audience with about 15% views per post | No stop loss or losing trade shown in 145 posts |
| Clear market commentary on BTC, ETH and gold | Wide stop losses at 10x to 20x leverage |
| Says it does not manage funds | No full VIP record, no refund policy found |
Is Coin Signals Legit or a Scam?
We can't call Coin Signals a scam based on public posts. The channel is real, the audience is active and the signals are properly built, with a stop loss on every one. But it is not transparent. The free channel only forwards signals as proof once they have won, losses never appear, and the monthly results are single big numbers you can't check. We would not pay for the VIP without first seeing a full list of its signals, losses included, for at least a few months.
Coin Signals vs Bullstar Signals
| Coin Signals | Bullstar Signals | |
|---|---|---|
| Full signals you can see | Only winning signals, forwarded as proof | Full VIP signals, stop loss included, forwarded to the public results channel |
| Stop loss on signals | Yes | On every signal |
| Losses posted | None seen | Every stop loss on the public results page |
| Track record | None | Every closed VIP signal since 2022 |
| Price | $365 to $500 a year | Listed on the website |
We are biased here, so compare for yourself: our results page lists every VIP signal since 2022 with the losses in it, and our free Telegram channel is open to anyone.
Best Coin Signals Alternatives
If you want a signals group where you can check more before paying, these channels scored higher on the same six points. Tap a name for our full review.
1. Bullstar Signals (9.2/10)
Our own channel. Every closed VIP signal since 2022 is on a public results page, stop losses included, and every signal has an entry zone, targets and a stop loss.
2. RAVEN Signals Pro (7.5/10)
Crypto and forex signals with a stop loss on every call and weekly reports that include losing days.
3. AltSignals (7.5/10)
A long-running group with a public results page and stop losses on its calls, though the free channel shows few full signals.
4. Binance Killers (6.7/10)
One of the largest channels on Telegram. Calls come with a stop loss and losses are posted, but there is no full record to check.
5. Fat Pig Signals (6.7/10)
Posts monthly summaries with win and loss counts, though stop losses were not on every call we saw.
You can compare every channel side by side in our best crypto signals Telegram groups ranking.
Who Is Coin Signals For?
If you want a free feed of market commentary and to see how a well-structured futures signal looks, the free channel is worth following. If you want to judge the VIP before paying, the free channel won't help much, because it only forwards signals that have already won.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Coin Signals legit?
It is a real, active channel with about 71K subscribers and solid engagement, and its signals include a stop loss. But it only shows winning trades, forwarded as proof after they hit their targets, so the VIP results can't be fully checked. It scores 4.2 out of 10 on our transparency points.
How much does Coin Signals VIP cost?
The pinned offer is $365 a year, described as a limited deal before the price rises to $500 a year. You join by messaging @Last_Satoshi or through the @Vip_CoinSignals_bot. We found no refund policy.
Does Coin Signals use stop losses?
Yes. Every full signal we saw in the free channel had a stop loss. At the suggested 10x to 20x leverage, the stops would cost 35% to 71% of the trade margin if hit.
Are Coin Signals free signals live?
Not in our sample. The full signals in the free channel are proof posts: each of the 9 we saw was forwarded together with its "all targets achieved" result after the trade had closed.
What are the best Coin Signals alternatives?
Channels that show more before you pay, such as Bullstar Signals, RAVEN Signals Pro and AltSignals, which post stop losses and publish results that include losing trades.
What is the official Coin Signals Telegram?
The channel is @coin_signals, and VIP requests go to @Last_Satoshi, as listed in the channel bio. Be careful with anyone who messages you first.
Final Thoughts
Coin Signals does several things right: real engagement, a stop loss on every signal and no fund management. Its proof posts show the winning signals were real. What it doesn't do is show its losing trades or let you follow a signal live before it plays out. Before you pay any signals group, look for three things: complete signals with a stop loss, losses posted next to the wins, and a record you can check. Coin Signals has the first one, but not the other two.
This review is for information only and is not financial advice. Crypto trading, especially with leverage, carries a high risk of loss.

